Hood Underground
heart and soul of our Fort Hood community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Hood Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

Is spanking the dog okay?

who's talking here?

I run with scissors 1
Maria 2
Kim 1
Shai 1
Mommy2two 1
Kelly 1
Pam 2
FieryFillies 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Maria --- 18 years ago -

I take my son to fix his hair this morning for school....and come back to find the dog enjoying a plate of pancakes and licking up the last of the syrup!! I wasn't mad really....as my son was nearly finished. But the dog has never attempted to jump up and eat our food before. So I ordered the dog to "get down" and "go to bed" which is his crate and he refused!! So I went to pick him up and he snipped at me!!! I ended up spanking him on his butt/thigh and telling him "No" sternly and then put him in his crate. Was that the right thing to do? I never spanked him before....but it was like my motherly side took over. =) 

Kim --- 18 years ago -

I've done the same thing! My animals are like my kids! You've got to teach the dogs right from wrong also. 

Shai --- 18 years ago -

I do the same thing too. I agree with Kim. Your dog needs to know that he is doing something wrong so he won't do it again. 

Mommy2two --- 18 years ago -

It's okay to discipline animals, just like children. It isn't abuse or anything like that (not what you described anyway). I've got a mutt that we love to death and she is a chewer! You name it, she eats it! Makes me want to pull my hair out! 

Kelly --- 18 years ago -

our dog will eat anything I sometimes catch him stealing the food out of the babies hand 1 spanking wont kill him, he has to learn somehow 

Maria --- 18 years ago -

M2t, "I've got a mutt that we love to death and she is a chewer!" Luckily I've not had to deal with that. That would drive me nuts if I had a dog that chewed everthing. Have you tried one of those "kong" toys? I hear you put treats in it and that keeps them busy for hours. 

Pam --- 18 years ago -

When I try to discipline our youngest Golden (14 months), she lays on her back, wags her tail and smiles at me ..how can I discipline her after that? lol 

I run with scissors --- 18 years ago -

that sounds like my dogs Pam. lol. They have such cute personalities. 

Pam --- 18 years ago -

We have 3 Goldens..10, 4 and 14 months..and they all have personalities plus. Having all 3 of them is like running a day care...toys all over the house! Our youngest is the one we got off of HYS..and the best thing we ever did. Our oldest 2 were acting sluggish, but his cutie pie walked in and all hell broke loose! lol 

FieryFillies --- 18 years ago -

I am a vet tech- trainers will say never spank a dog- but hey they do need it sometimes- especially if your dog snapped at you- the only thing I would say was wrong was then putting the dog in the crate. The crate is the dog's safe zone and should never be used as punishment. I have a 10 month old Boxer- boy is he a handful- I was able to borrow a shock collar from a friend. No matter what I tried he would not stop stealing food and getting in the trash- now I can punish him for what he is doing- he associates what he is doing as wrong and not with me spanking or yelling at him. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children
parenting

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Hood Underground